Most English marks don't stall on talent. They stall on habits.
If you're wondering how to improve English marks in high school, start with the small, fixable habits that drain points from every essay: skipped feedback, missed instructions, last-minute drafts and safe, thin answers. Fix those one at a time and the mark can climb before your teen's writing changes at all.
I'm an Ontario Certified Teacher and a high school English teacher by training, with 14 years in education (more on my About the Founder page), and I've marked more teen essays than I can count. The same seven habits show up again and again. Here's how to spot each one, and what to do about it this week.
English marks stall because the work changes and the habits don't. In grade 9 and beyond, a fluent summary no longer earns a high mark. Teachers want an argument, proof from the text and an explanation of why that proof matters. That's a steep jump, and I unpack it in my post on grade 9 English in Ontario.
The marks themselves come from four areas Ontario teachers use for every subject, set out in the province's Growing Success assessment policy: Knowledge and Understanding, Thinking, Communication and Application. A teen can write clean, tidy sentences and still lose marks in Thinking if the ideas stay on the surface.
The stakes are rising too. Starting in 2026-27, Ontario's assessment rules add attendance and participation to final high school marks (15% in grades 9 and 10, 10% in grades 11 and 12) and add mandatory written exams in most subjects. Showing up, speaking up and studying all count for more than they did a year ago.
In my experience, teens who read well and talk well tend to coast in English. They've been told they're "good at it," so they skip the planning and the rereading. That breezy confidence works until grade 9 or 10, when the marks start rewarding analysis over fluency.
The fix: ask your teen to show you the rubric before they start. When they see "uses specific evidence" and "explains its significance," the shortcut looks less tempting.
Every writer has one leak that costs them marks on every assignment. For some it's run-on sentences. For others it's quotes dropped in with no explanation, or a thesis that hides in the last paragraph. Few teens know which leak is theirs, so they fix a different one each time.
The fix: have your teen write their top three mistakes on a sticky note and check every draft against it before they hand it in. If neither of you can name those three, the Learning X-Ray™ answers that question for English: it looks beneath the report card mark at the hidden micro skills, like organizing ideas, logical transitions and self-correction, and gives you a Performance Report and a step-by-step Roadmap measured against Ontario curriculum standards for your teen's grade.
Most teens I've taught flip straight to the mark and ignore the comments. That's a shame, because the comments are the map. A note like "develop your analysis" shows up on paper after paper until someone acts on it.
The fix: when an assignment comes back, ask one question: "What's the one comment you'll fix next time?" If the report card comment worries you, here's what "progressing with difficulty" means in English, and here are the questions to ask at parent-teacher interviews to get a clear answer from the teacher.
A due date three weeks away feels like a rumour. Then it's Sunday at 10 p.m., and a five-paragraph essay is being written in one breathless sitting. Rushed essays lose marks in every category, and in grades 7 to 12, Ontario teachers may deduct marks for late work.
The fix: break the essay into four mini deadlines: thesis, outline, draft, revision. Put each one on the family calendar. If the draft stalls at the paragraph level, my guide on how to write a paragraph walks through the structure step by step.
Plenty of what looks like laziness is a skill gap in a hoodie. A teen who doesn't know how to start an analysis will stall, scroll, or ask a chatbot to start it for them. The work gets done. The thinking doesn't, and it shows on in-class writing and exams, where there's no chatbot to lean on.
The fix: make the first step smaller ("write your thesis in one sentence") and keep AI out of the idea stage. I share practical house rules in my post on kids using AI for homework. Thinking first, AI second.
Teens who fear being wrong write short, careful answers that say what everyone else said. It feels safe. It also caps the Thinking mark, because a strong English answer takes a position and defends it.
The fix: praise the bold idea before you mention the commas. "That's an interesting reading of the ending. How would you prove it?" tells your teen that taking a stance is the goal.
A beautiful essay on the wrong question still loses marks. Teens skim the task, miss a required part (a quote from each chapter, a counterargument, a works cited page) and lose easy points they'd already earned.
The fix: before writing, your teen turns the assignment sheet into a checklist. My full guide on how to help your child follow instructions at school covers this habit in detail.
A common pattern: sharp ideas, clean sentences and a mark that stings, because the essay has three quotes and zero explanation. Add two sentences of "this shows that..." after each quote, and the essay has what the rubric asks for.
Rubrics reward work, not wishes. One habit, practised, earns a mark that means something.
Good marks in English come from steady practice with feedback, not from one heroic all-nighter. This routine takes about 20 minutes a week of your time:
If motivation is the sticking point, my post on whether you should pay kids for good grades shows which rewards help and which backfire. The Ontario secondary English curriculum lists what each course expects, and if a literacy test is coming, EQAO's OSSLT page explains the reading and writing skills it measures.
Improving English marks in high school isn't about a smarter kid. It's about a sharper routine: know the weak spot, read the comments, plan the essay and take a real position. Pick one habit from this list and work on it for a month. Then pick the next.
Want your teen to build these skills with steady support? See how our online English courses, opening soon, weave critical thinking into reading and writing, so your teen learns to think it through before they write it down.
Comments will be approved before showing up.
Rachel Esco
Author