Child Not Following Instructions at School? How to Help


by Rachel Esco February 06, 2018

Smiling girl in a pink and green striped top at her desk with a notebook

Missing instructions isn't a character flaw. It's a reading skill that hasn't clicked yet.

Is your child not following instructions at school? In my experience, the cause comes down to one of three things: they skim the task, they lose track of steps partway through, or they don't know what words like "explain" and "compare" are asking for. The fix is to teach them to slow down and read the task like a checklist: mark each step, say it back in their own words, and check the finished work against it.

I'm an Ontario Certified Teacher with 14 years in education (more on my About the Founder page), and in English class I've watched strong students lose easy marks this way for years. The good news: I've found this habit responds to practice faster than most things on the report card.

Why kids miss instructionsMost kids I've taught who miss instructions aren't ignoring them.
1SkimmingKids read the first line, assume they know the rest and start writing.
2Step overloadMany younger kids hold one or two and drop the rest.
3Fuzzy task wordsA child who treats them as the same word answers the wrong question.
4Tuning outBy the time the child looks up, everyone else has started.

Why is my child not following instructions at school?

Most kids I've taught who miss instructions aren't ignoring them. They're reading too fast, holding too many steps at once, or guessing at what the task wants. Here's what I saw most:

  • Skimming. Kids read the first line, assume they know the rest and start writing. The second half of the task (the part with the marks) goes unread.
  • Step overload. "Read the chapter, choose two quotes, explain each one and connect them to the theme" is four jobs in one sentence. Many younger kids hold one or two and drop the rest.
  • Fuzzy task words. "Describe," "explain," "compare" and "analyze" each ask for something different. A child who treats them as the same word answers the wrong question.
  • Tuning out. Daydreams, side chats and phones pull attention away during the moment the teacher explains the assignment. By the time the child looks up, everyone else has started.

If the struggle shows up everywhere, at school and beyond, and doesn't budge with practice, mention it to your child's teacher. Attention or learning needs can sit underneath, and the school team can help you look into it.

Following instructions is a reading skill

Instructions are a short, dense piece of text, and reading them well uses the same skills as reading a story: finding the main idea, noticing key words and keeping track of details. That's why, in my experience, a child who misses instructions tends to struggle with reading comprehension questions too. If you've wondered about that link, my post on how to tell if your child is reading at grade level is a good place to look next.

Ontario report cards track it as well. One of the sample behaviours for the "Independent Work" learning skill in Growing Success, Ontario's assessment policy, is that the student "follows instructions with minimal supervision." So this habit shows up twice: in the marks and in the learning skills.

Not sure whether your child is tuning out or misreading? From the outside the two look identical, and they need different fixes. In the Learning X-Ray™, your child reads selected material and explains their answers out loud, so an Ontario-certified teacher can hear the point where understanding slips. The Performance Report then shows how their reading comprehension measures up to Ontario curriculum standards for their grade. If it's on track, the fix is more likely a focus habit than reading practice.

How to get your child to follow instructions: 5 steps

These steps work for any written task, from a grade 3 book report to a grade 12 essay. Practise them together for a few weeks, then let your child run them solo. Following instructions is a responsibility, not a talent. Kids who learn to own it at home carry the habit into every class, and later into every job.

Mark every stepA sentence with four jobs gets four marks.
1One highlight per job✓Circle the task words
1Read the chapter, 2choose two quotes, 3explain each one 4and connect them to the theme
This turns a wall of words into bite-sized pieces.

1. Mark every step

Have your child underline or highlight each separate thing the task asks for. One highlight per job. A sentence with four jobs gets four marks. This turns a wall of words into bite-sized pieces.

2. Circle the task words

Circle the verbs that tell them what to do, then check what each one means:

  • Describe: tell what it looks like or what happened.
  • Explain: tell why or how.
  • Compare: show how two things are alike and different.
  • Analyze: break it into parts and show what each part does.
  • Support: back it up with proof from the text.

These task words turn up on assignment sheets in every grade I've taught, and they matter more each year. The Ontario language curriculum sets out what your child is expected to do at each grade.

3. Say it back

Ask your child to explain the task to you in their own words, without looking at the sheet. If they can't, they haven't understood it yet, and that's the moment to reread together, before an hour of work heads in the wrong direction. Rephrasing also brings up the questions they forgot to ask in class.

4. Turn the sheet into a checklist

Number each step in the margin. When a step is done, it gets a check. Before handing in, your child runs down the list one last time. This takes two minutes and catches the missing works cited page, the skipped second quote and the forgotten title.

5. Compare the work to the rubric

When the assignment comes back, look at the rubric together. Did marks drop because a required part was missing? Name it out loud ("You lost marks because there was no conclusion") so the lesson lands. Over a few assignments, you'll see those gaps close.

A common pattern: lively, well-organized writing loses marks because it answers "describe" when the task says "explain." Once your child circles the task word before writing a single sentence, those marks start coming back.

By ageFollowing instructions is a responsibility, not a talent.
Grades 2 to 5Keep spoken directions to one or two steps, then ask your child to repeat them.
Grades 6 to 8Teach the checklist habit now, while the stakes are lower.
Grades 9 to 12Teens face multi-part essays, timed tests and the literacy test, where each question asks for something specific.

How to get your child to follow directions in school, by age

Grades 2 to 5. Keep spoken directions to one or two steps, then ask your child to repeat them. For written tasks, read the instructions aloud together and let them point to each step.

Grades 6 to 8. Assignments get longer and come with rubrics. Teach the checklist habit now, while the stakes are lower. This is also when paragraph structure starts to matter, and my guide on how to write a paragraph shows the pieces teachers look for.

Grades 9 to 12. Teens face multi-part essays, timed tests and the literacy test, where each question asks for something specific. Reading the question twice is a real strategy on the literacy test (EQAO's OSSLT page explains what it measures), and my guide Is the OSSLT Hard? covers how to prepare.

When to talk to the teacher

If missed instructions keep costing marks after a month of practice, bring it up with the teacher. Ask which kinds of tasks trip your child up and whether instructions are given out loud, in writing or both. My list of questions to ask at parent-teacher interviews includes a few that work well here.

Missed instructions are also one of the seven habits I cover in how to improve English marks in high school, along with six others that drain points without anyone noticing.

Careful reading is a thinking skill, and it grows with practice. See how our online English courses, opening soon, build that habit, one task at a time, with feedback that helps your child fix mistakes on the spot.




Rachel Esco
Rachel Esco

Author



Leave a comment :)

Comments will be approved before showing up.


Also in School Scoop

How to Write a Thesis Statement in Grade 9: Weak vs Strong
How to Write a Thesis Statement in Grade 9: Weak vs Strong

by Rachel Esco, OCT November 19, 2026

How to write a thesis statement in grade 9: a simple one-sentence formula, weak and strong examples side by side, what grade 10 adds, and how to use it on Ontario's new final exam.

Read More

How to Study for an English Exam You Can't Memorize
How to Study for an English Exam You Can't Memorize

by Rachel Esco, OCT November 19, 2026

How to study for an English exam when there's nothing to memorize: why rereading falls short, what Ontario's new mandatory final exams mean, and a 4-week plan built on timed writing.

Read More

How to Write a Summary in Grades 4 to 8: Main-Idea Method
How to Write a Summary in Grades 4 to 8: Main-Idea Method

by Rachel Esco, OCT November 18, 2026

How to write a summary in grades 4 to 8: find the main idea, keep two or three key details, and say it in your own words, with original grade 4 and grade 8 examples.

Read More